Damages, information and inspection

What an infringement really costs: three methods of calculating damages, accounting, inspection and disclosure of documents.

An injunction does not close a case. Economically, the quantum phase is often decisive: what quantities were sold, what profit was made, and how is the damage calculated?

What we do

  • Claims for information and rendering of accounts
  • Calculation by licence analogy, infringer's profit or lost profit
  • Inspection and disclosure claims
  • Recall, destruction and publication of the judgment
  • Quantum proceedings and settlement

Legal framework

German law recognises three methods: actual damage, a reasonable licence fee and surrender of the infringer's profit. The basis is the Enforcement Directive 2004/48/EC.

In preparation, claims exist for information on origin and distribution channels and for inspection and production of documents (section 140c PatG, section 19a MarkenG, section 101a UrhG).

At the UPC, damages and accounting are dealt with in a separate procedural stage; the Court of Appeal issued several leading decisions on this in 2026.

How we proceed

  1. Demand information
  2. Check the data
  3. Calculate
  4. Quantum action or settlement

Four cases from practice

Anonymised and simplified. Every case depends on its facts.

Infringer's profit

An imitator had earned high margins. Surrender of the infringer's profit yielded considerably more than a notional licence.

Incomplete information

The information provided omitted suppliers. A coercive fine application and an affidavit completed the data.

Inspection of software

Suspected copying of code was confirmed by an expert in inspection proceedings.

Recall from trade

Besides damages we obtained a recall of goods from distribution channels so that remaining stock was no longer sold.

Frequently asked questions

Which calculation method is best?

That depends on the figures. You can choose between the methods until the end.

Do I have to prove the exact damage?

Not for the licence analogy; the court estimates a reasonable fee.

When does the claim become time-barred?

Usually three years from knowledge, with residual claims under unjust enrichment.

Discuss your matter

Write to us or place an order directly. No fields are mandatory.